14 Comments
User's avatar
PGBreaker's avatar

So, why is James Tibbs the Third always refered to as 'James Tibbs the Third.' The name doesn't flow easily, and I my mouth--and maybe yours--moves in eight distinct, consecutive directions to grind that name out. What is wrong with J.T. Three? My mouth barely moves on that one. Or better, Jimmy Tibbs? Flowing with a jaunty, fun lilt. I feel like 'James Tibbs the Third' should be reserved for when he is inducted in the Baseball Hall of Fame or the House of Lords in London or something. Maybe I've got too much time on my hands...

Expand full comment
Graham L's avatar

If Matos needs to go back to AAA, what would be the implications for the rest of the Sacramento roster? Also, do you think he should?

Expand full comment
totalfan62's avatar

Thanks again for all the great content on There R Giants, Roger. Must read on everything you post. My question for this mailbag: who are the best catchers in the Giants MiLB system, and what are those best prospects outlook for reaching the MLB roster? Bailey is an excellent defensive catcher, but he has looked lost and overwhelmed at bat this season (continuing a trend from last two seasons). Strong defense and "pitcher whisperer" skills are very important, but we need at least a .225 batting average/.700ish OPS from that position. Any options in the short term beyond veteran backups like Huff and Stassi?

Expand full comment
Jim W's avatar

Hi Roger,

Thanks for the great system coverage. What’s Victor Bericoto’s injury status? Will he continue to 1B at-bats at AAA once healthy? Know he got off to slow start but would like to see him get a shot and see where it leads.

Expand full comment
Scott's avatar

Roger, thanks for all the great info you put out on a regular basis, really enjoy all your work.

With lots of injuries around the league, and the Giants mostly healthy (knocking on wood), seems like they are in a good place to maximize the trade value from one of our depth pieces. Any idea which Giants player, from any level in the org, peaking in value that could pull a decent return in a trade?

Extra credit on who the Giants should target in this trade, or maybe just a comp to a past trade.

Expand full comment
Henrique Goncalves's avatar

Rog, what is your take on trying Luciano at 1B? I understand the ML team’s big need, I just worry about another positional move for him now that he was getting the grasp of playing LF.

Expand full comment
joe's avatar

Who do YOU want them to draft in July

Expand full comment
MikeH's avatar

Beat me to the question, Joe - seems a very average draft...

Expand full comment
Small Winged Yeti's avatar

The Max Muncy astigmatism story made me curious about this. In your estimate, what percentage of the hitters in the org have done something to correct their eye sight (contacts, glasses, lasik, anything)? And is this an important factor for scouts (esp. for the draft), or is this something consider solvable medically? Thank you.

Expand full comment
David Wright's avatar

It seems to me “JUCO Barry Bonds” doesn’t need to prove himself at Eugene anymore. Do you think after the draft, they promote Bo to Richmond and try and breathe some life into that moribund offense?

Expand full comment
David Wright's avatar

In reading the tea leaves and Buster’s comments on the radio, I think Giants will be taking action regarding our 1B Situation. Do you think they will be desperate enough to bring up Eldridge and let him cut his teeth at major level? Surely he can hit better than .182!!!

Expand full comment
David Wright's avatar

Roger, thank for all you do! Could you put in context the different affiliate levels versus college teams -say D-1 /SEC level college programs. Would like the current San Jose Giants beat a good SEC team? Or would the Giants ACL beat a decent college team?

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Robert's avatar

Have the Posey admin giants changed their facilities access policy for rival scouts?

Expand full comment
Aaron Girard's avatar

Has the tide finally turned for the Giants farm from pitching heavy to slightly favoring the hitters? Sure seems like most of the players performing well this season are on the offensive side. Bullpen arms especially seem to have dwindled.

Expand full comment